For a brief period this month, Justice Gabriel Scott Pwamang has occupied the chair at the top of Ghana’s Judiciary. It is only temporary. Chief Justice Paul Baffoe-Bonnie is away from the jurisdiction, and Justice Pwamang, the most senior Justice of the Supreme Court, has been designated to act in his stead. It is a familiar judicial arrangement. When the Chief Justice is unavailable, the most senior Justice steps in to perform the administrative functions of the office.
But this particular period of acting leadership has acquired an interesting significance. In just over a month, the chair will become vacant for good. Chief Justice Baffoe-Bonnie, who has served on the Supreme Court since 2008 and became Chief Justice in November 2025, is expected to retire on 26 December 2026 upon attaining the constitutionally prescribed age of 70.
Naturally, attention has now shifted to the question of succession. Who gets the President’s nod?
The Constitution, by its article 144, places the appointment of the Chief Justice in the hands of the President, acting in consultation with the Council of State and subject to the approval of Parliament. Two names have, however, emerged prominently in the conversation: Justice Gabriel Scott Pwamang and Justice Emmanuel Yonny Kulendi.
One represents seniority, institutional continuity and familiarity with the administration of the Judiciary. The other represents a different route to the apex court, having arrived there directly from a distinguished career at the Bar.
The case for Pwamang
Justice Pwamang is, in the most literal sense, the natural name to begin with.
Appointed to the Supreme Court in 2015, he is currently the longest-serving Justice after the Chief Justice. He has therefore spent more than a decade on the apex bench and has had considerable opportunity to understand not only the adjudicatory work of the Supreme Court but also the institutional machinery surrounding it.
His recent designation as Acting Chief Justice has given him another advantage of sorts. But how long would Pwamang have? He was born on 17 August 1960. That means that if he were appointed Chief Justice now, his tenure would run only until August 2030, when he reaches the mandatory retirement age of 70.
There is also the question of inclusivity. Justice Pwamang has an observable physical impairment. His physical condition has been noticed publicly and has inevitably prompted questions about whether, and to what extent, it should enter the appointment calculus.
That question becomes particularly interesting against the backdrop of a government that has consistently spoken about inclusion and the need to create space for persons with disabilities to participate fully in public life. Could the President, therefore, be weighed against the very language of inclusivity his government has championed if the physical condition of a candidate becomes a consideration in choosing who leads the Judiciary?
There is no easy answer, and perhaps there should not be one until the President’s decision is made.
Disability should not, merely by reason of its visibility, become an automatic disqualification. But neither should the language of inclusion turn disability into an automatic qualification.
The Kulendi Proposition
Justice Kulendi was appointed to the Supreme Court in 2020, but his route to the apex court was markedly different from that of many of his colleagues. He came directly from private legal practice.
Before his appointment, he had built a substantial career at the Bar and was associated with Kulendi @ Law, where he served as managing partner. Born on 29 November 1963, Kulendi would reach the mandatory retirement age in November 2033. An appointment now could therefore give him almost seven years at the head of the Judiciary.
Longevity is not a substitute for ability. But where the office involves long-term institutional projects, administrative reforms and the development of judicial policy, the possibility of a longer tenure is not an insignificant consideration.
But this is not simply a contest between age and seniority. It would be too easy to reduce the choice to arithmetic. Pwamang is older, more senior and has been on the Supreme Court longer. Kulendi is younger and could potentially serve longer. But the more important distinction may be between two conceptions of judicial leadership. Pwamang represents continuity. Kulendi potentially represents renewal.
Neither is inherently superior.
The Choice Ahead
The President’s eventual decision will inevitably be scrutinised professionally, institutionally and, inevitably, politically. But the constitutional question is not simply who is next in line.
What, then, should Ghana demand from its next Chief Justice? Seniority should matter, but it should not become an automatic entitlement. Experience should matter, but experience must be matched by the ability to lead an institution facing contemporary problems. Intellectual brilliance should matter, but the Chief Justice is not merely the author of judgments.
Administrative competence should matter. Judicial independence should matter. The ability to command the confidence of the Bench and the wider legal profession should matter.
And perhaps, above all, the next Chief Justice must understand that leading the Judiciary is not simply about occupying the highest judicial office in the country. It is about protecting the credibility of an institution on which the public ultimately depends for the vindication of rights, the resolution of disputes and the administration of justice.
By December, the speculation may well have ended. Ghana will know who has been chosen to lead the third arm of government into the years ahead.
